13th annual Municipal Finance Conference


13th annual Municipal Finance Conference


Empowering women entrepreneurs in developing countries

Why current programs fall short

Lucia Mayta, 43, and her daughter Luz Cecilia, 12, pose for a photograph inside their bodega in La Paz February 24, 2014. Lucia studied until the fourth grade of primary school, and knows how to read and write and do basic math. Lucia runs a bodega, and the family live in a back room. She hopes to build a house in the future. Luz Cecilia is in seventh grade and wants to be a singer. On March 8 activists around the globe celebrate International Women's Day, which dates back to the beginning of the 20th century and has been observed by the United Nations since 1975. The UN writes that it is an occasion to commemorate achievements in women's rights and to call for further change. Picture taken February 24, 2014. REUTERS/David Mercado (BOLIVIA - Tags: SOCIETY EDUCATION)ATTENTION EDITORS: PICTURE 11 OF 32 FOR PACKAGE 'WOMEN'S DAY - MOTHERS AND DAUGHTERS' TO FIND ALL IMAGES SEARCH 'REUTERS MOTHERS DAUGHTERS' - GM1EA370T5701

Current women’s economic empowerment interventions are not enough to overcome all obstacles facing female entrepreneurs. The emerging evidence from psychology and experimental economics on agency, mindset, and leadership show that for successful interventions to be transformative, they need to move beyond basic access to financial and human capital and also tackle central psychological, social, and skills constraints on women entrepreneurs. Emerging evidence from recent studies on different capital-based, training-based, and gender-based interventions, using randomized control trials, present promising interventions to support women entrepreneurs.

An experimental study in Uganda found that providing financial capital (i.e., subsidized microcredit coupled with Start and Improve Your Business training module), while effective for men, does not have any impact on female-owned enterprise profits. Similarly, a randomized control trial on Tanzania’s Business Women Connect program found that while the mobile savings program substantially increased savings, it did not have an effect on female-owned enterprise profits or sales even when combined with hard business skills, such as business management, basic profitability concepts, and record-keeping. Both studies, however, show that loans paired with business trainings as well as improved access to mobile savings accounts paired with business trainings had a positive impact on male-owned microenterprise profits or sales. Thus, a successful women’s economic empowerment intervention needs more than only access to financial capital and hard business skills.

On the other hand, a randomized field experiment on Nicaragua’s Small Business of the Family Economy program found that business trainings significantly increased self-employed men and women’s real income—with a higher impact for women. This impact could be due to the nature of the training’s program itself; the program not only provided production techniques, business organization, and administrative skills but also had talks about creation of business plans, networking, establishment of virtual stores, and access to new markets components.

More importantly, men and women entrepreneurs face inherently different constraints including psychological and cultural factors. Female entrepreneurs are often lacking in access to financial and human capital, which impedes business growth; have different mindset constraints, such as risk-aversion; and have not caught up in soft skills, such as leadership. In addition, women have culturally-imposed constraints that psychologically and physically impede their independence, aspiration, and priorities. Thus, the success of female entrepreneurs depends on their personal traits and entrepreneurial skills, and how supportive institutions and stakeholders address or work around these major constraints.

To truly empower women, policymakers needs to address these constraints. Andrea Cornwall—a leading anthropologist from the University of Sussex—proposes two elements of change: First, consciousness needs to be shifted—overturning internalized constraints and aspirational barriers that keep women in situations of subordination—and second, cultural beliefs about gender and power must be challenged.

Shift in Consciousness and Mindset

In comparison to men, many disadvantaged female microentrepreneurs suffer from mindset constraints. For instance, a study on Tanzania’s PRIDE training program shows that women are more risk-averse than men are. A lab experiment, after financial capital and basic business training intervention, found that women still engage in fewer competitive scenarios than men do. This type of mindset inhibits profits and overall improvement of business performance. The lab experiment looking at mindset constraints found that, with the same intervention (which taught soft skills around entrepreneurial characters such as long-term view and orientation in business, self-confidence, and managing people), men, not constrained in this way, saw a significant increase in sales.

Some business training programs, specifically set out to shift mindsets, found a positive impact on female entrepreneurs. For instance, a personal-initiative training program in Togo, run by World Bank’s Gender Innovation Lab, offered psychology-based “mindset” training for both male and female business owners. The soft skills included self-starting behaviors, innovation, identifying and exploiting new opportunities, goal setting, planning, and feedback cycles, and overcoming obstacles. The training program found business performance improvements for both male and female enterprises, and interestingly, the main effect of the training on women seemed to be an increase in women’s personal initiative. In addition, the effect on women’s soft skills post-training held constant regardless of education level (with slight differentiations along training background).

Labor market studies also find that mindset interventions prove effective by either instilling aspirations or shifting perceptions of labor market opportunities (whether in formal employment or self-employment). A study in Ethiopia showed that a one-hour video to rural farmers showing successful peers was effective in shifting future-oriented behaviors. Another study in India that provided information to rural women on job opportunities for them in the outsourcing industry, led to more education, lower desired fertility, and higher likelihood of entering the job market

Challenging gender identities

Another pivotal component to any intervention seeking to make a transformative change is challenging gender identity roles. In Tanzania’s PRIDE study cited above, for instance, women report spending on average 10 hours less in their businesses per week than men. The component of owner’s time is a critically binding constraint, notably for enterprises with fewer employees. Women also report having lesser say in important household and business decisions and diverting business resources to household expenditures, due to either external pressures or lack of self-control. A randomized control trial experiment in Kenya found that expanding access to savings accounts increased the probability of saving for self-employed women working as market vendors, and increased their productive investment and private expenditures, implying significant barriers to savings and investment. Another gender component inhibiting women is the crowding-out effect, meaning women are stopped from expanding their businesses because capital grant led to a reduction of external financial support from their spouses.

Business training interventions emphasizing the need to challenge or work around gender identities, in addition to soft skills and shifting mindsets, have found a small but positive shift in perspective. Liberia’s Economic Empowerment of Adolescent Girls training program included hard and technical skills such as office computer skills and accommodated the special needs of female entrepreneurs—safe locations and free childcare. Studied through a randomized control trial, the training program was found to increase earnings of female entrepreneurs and positively affect female self-confidence and self-assessed entrepreneurial ability. The most significant finding is the program saw a small but positive shift in self-reported gender role perspective—meaning survey respondents were more likely to report that both men and women should take care of household responsibilities.

Teaching life skills and providing technology solutions

Trainings that go beyond financial capital and basic business skills, and teach necessary life skills have also shown a small, but positive impact on female-owned microenterprises. For instance, a Peruvian training program provided to clients of FINCA-Peru, a microfinance institution, taught general business skills such as how to calculate production costs and product pricing in addition to life skills such as separating business and home finances. The result—found through randomized control trials—was a positive, albeit small, impact of the Peruvian training program on female-led enterprise revenues.

Similarly, a randomized control trial on Tanzania’s Business Women Connect program, cited above, found that women save substantially more through a mobile savings account. The same study found that providing women with a business skills training bolstered the effect. A higher proportion of married women who participated in the mobile savings program reported that they were the sole decisionmakers about their own personal expenditures than those who did not participate in the program. Thus, the mobile savings program has had unexpected empowerment outcomes for women, though it did not influence female-owned enterprise profits or sales.

To summarize, successful interventions, among studies reviewed above, have usually paired basic business skills provision (as we all as basic financial capital) with provision of soft skills such as leadership and mindset considerations. Moreover, programs that address or work around socially imposed gender roles increase female understanding of inhibiting normative assumptions.

Implications for policy and practice

  1. Providing business skills trainings is a basic step toward empowering women entrepreneurs, but to truly achieve transformative change, training programs need to address deeper psychological and social constraints facing women. In practice though, skill-centric interventions are hard to get right—they have high dropout rates, are less cost-effective compared to capital-focused programs (grants and assets in particular, though not microcredits), and often need to be complemented by capital injection. Three of the common traits of successful skills interventions include demand-driven (i.e., provided skills that are missing and binding to enterprise performance), market-centric (i.e., provided trainings which taught identifying new market opportunities or addressed existing market failures), and consideration of the entrepreneur (i.e., gender lens) to leverage strength and address specific constraints.
  2. Similarly, financial access, while a basic step in women’s economic empowerment, cannot alone help grow subsistence enterprises owned by woman who face multiple binding constraints. While advances in technology, in-kind grants, and life skills training programs assist female entrepreneurs in keeping their professional and personal savings accounts safe and separate, and address key saving and investment constraints, there is a widespread concern about microcredits. Notably, the type and the institutional arrangements of the loan (i.e., size, tenor, terms, and type of financial institution) define the success, cost-effectiveness, and attractiveness of microcredits. The conversation needs to shift toward making credit markets work better for women.
  3. Finally, a clear measure of success is important. Provision of basic technical business training programs, at best, improved business practice of women-owned enterprises, often without any significant progress in business performance or empowerment more broadly. While some interventions have improved both economic and subjective well-being of female entrepreneurs, it is generally hard to grow employment in SMEs. Conventional micro-interventions providing access to credit and business training for the poor have also proven ineffective in bringing major changes in women’s economic empowerment. Sustaining women’s empowerment hinges on the longevity and effectiveness of program interventions and on continuous policy commitment to inclusion and equality.