If, despite the best efforts of President Hugo Chávez’s electoral sorcerers, the Venezuelan opposition captures a significant share of the seats in this Sunday, September 26’s legislative elections, there will be no dearth of explanations for the government’s debacle. In more ways than one can count, Venezuela is in a dire predicament. Amid daily blackouts and the highest inflation in Latin America, the International Monetary Fund expects the Venezuelan economy to contract yet again in 2010, alone among the region’s booming economies. Few narratives, however, will be as compelling as the country’s descent into crime hell.
Only a few days ago, Chávez stated unequivocally that “it is not true that Venezuela is one of the most dangerous countries in the world, nor is it true that today there is more violence here than there was 11 years ago.” Facts, however, are stubborn things. Since 1999, when Chávez took office, no Latin American country has seen a more acute deterioration in personal safety than Venezuela. The country’s homicide rate has gone from 20 per 100,000 people in 1998 to 49 per 100,000 in 2009 — nine times as high as in the United States. This places Venezuela solidly among the world’s most violent countries, alongside chronically bad cases such as Jamaica and Guatemala. In the capital city, Caracas, the rate is 122 per 100,000, a figure comparable only to that of Ciudad Juárez, the Mexican border town where drug traffickers are literally waging a war against the state and one other. Car theft rates, a good barometer of property crime (unlike other crimes, stolen cars are usually reported to the authorities), have also exploded from 69 per 100,000 people in 1998 to 155 in 2009.
No wonder, then, that crime — according to nearly every opinion poll carried out in the run-up to the election — tops voters’ concerns by a large margin. In August, the Venezuelan Institute for Data Analysis (IVAD) reported that 84 percent of voters mentioned insecurity as a major concern, while less than half that percentage mentioned unemployment, the second most important issue to voters. With the vote just around the corner, the opposition is running neck and neck with Chávez’s party and has a fighting chance of capturing a majority of the popular vote, though not of the heavily gerrymandered seats.
The government’s anxiety is palpable. Since 2004, it has refused to release official crime figures, leaving the task of compiling them to NGOs. In August, the government-controlled judiciary cautioned El Nacional, an opposition newspaper, against publishing images related to “blood, weapons and terror messages.” The warning followed the newspaper’s controversial decision to publish a large cover photo of wounded corpses in Caracas’s main morgue. True to form, Chávez has oscillated between blaming the remnants of capitalism for the mess and claiming that “the United States has infiltrated Venezuela … to kill, to kidnap people and then to say that Chávez can’t [govern effectively]” — that is, when he’s not denying that crime is a problem altogether.