Social Security Reform and National Saving in an Era of Budget Surpluses

Jeffrey B. Liebman and

JBL

Jeffrey B. Liebman Harvard University

Douglas Elmendorf

Douglas Elmendorf Harvard University Distinguished Service Professor - Harvard Kennedy School

Discussants: Matthew D. Shapiro and

MDS

Matthew D. Shapiro

Stephen P. Zeldes

SPZ

Stephen P. Zeldes

THE UNEXPECTED EMERGENCE of federal budget surpluses during the late
1990s, combined with official projections that these surpluses will continue
for decades to come, has significantly altered fiscal policymaking.
Congressional and administration budget proposals now aim to balance the
budget exclusive of Social Security, or exclusive of Social Security and
Medicare, rather than on an overall, or unified, basis. Some proposals state
the goal of paying off the entire stock of federal debt held by the public
within a decade and a half. This fiscal bounty has also altered the likely
avenues for Social Security and Medicare reform. Traditional options
for ensuring the programs’ financial stability—benefit cuts and tax
increases—have largely given way to new options focused on using the
expected surpluses to prefund future obligations.