The convenience yield compares a U.S. Treasury security’s yield to an otherwise comparable asset—such as a AAA-rated corporate bond or another advanced economy’s sovereign debt—with a similar maturity, risk, and payment profile.
When the convenience yield is positive, the U.S. government will pay less to borrow than others. In the past, estimated convenience yields for U.S. Treasuries were significant and positive because Treasuries were regarded as the ultimate safe asset: The market is large and liquid, and they’re widely accepted as high-quality collateral. But lately the estimated convenience yield on U.S. Treasuries has been shrinking.
Why do convenience yields matter?
Because the U.S. government is such a large borrower, even small increases in interest rates add up to a big number. Already, 15% of all federal spending goes to interest payments. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates that if interest rates over the next decade are half a percentage point higher than it currently projects, the deficit would be $1.9 trillion larger over 10 years.
How do economists measure the convenience yield?
To measure the convenience yield, economists want to compare the yield on U.S. Treasuries to other risk-free assets, but there aren’t any precisely comparable assets. One approach is to compare the yield on Treasuries to the yield on AAA corporate bonds, adjusted to account for risk and for differences such as a corporation’s ability to call a bond before maturity. But only two corporations (Microsoft and Johnson & Johnson) are currently rated AAA by the two largest credit rating agencies. One alternative is to construct a measure of a risk-free asset from market interest rates using interest rate swaps or certain trading strategies designed to completely hedge risk. Another alternative is to compare the yield of Treasuries to the yield of debt issued by other governments, adjusted for differences in exchange rates.
What has been happening to convenience yields? Why?
The Treasury convenience yield has been declining since the Great Recession of 2007-2008 and turned negative in the early 2010s for longer-maturity Treasury securities. Following the COVID pandemic in 2020, the convenience yield fell further. In other words, Treasury yields are closer to the yield on risk-adjusted AAA corporate bonds and currency-adjusted G10 sovereigns than they were before the Great Recession.
A measure by Wenxin Du of Harvard, Ritt Keerati of the Federal Reserve Board, and Jesse Schreger of Columbia shows that the convenience yield for 5-year Treasuries compared to G10 government bonds of the same maturity has declined by 17 basis points, from -11 basis points on average from 2012-2020 to -28 basis points on average from 2021-2025.
There are different explanations of the erosion in the convenience yield. Among them:
- Some researchers say the increase in U.S. Treasury debt issuance and fiscal concerns after the U.S. borrowed heavily to support the economy during the Great Recession and the COVID pandemic may have pushed the convenience yield on Treasury securities down. Bondholders may be getting less confident in the U.S. government’s ability or willingness to pay back the sums it has borrowed. Investors increasingly see U.S. Treasury debt as risky rather than safe, says Hanno Lustig of Stanford, due to worries that the government will not be able to collect enough revenue to repay it. He argues that central bankers and financial regulators haven’t grasped this new reality.
- Du, Keerati, and Schreger find that the more borrowing by foreign governments relative to U.S. borrowing, the more attractive U.S. Treasury securities, and thus the bigger the convenience yield estimate, and vice versa.
- Paul Cochran and co-authors at the Federal Reserve Board note that regulatory and other risk management constraints could limit dealers’ willingness to intermediate in Treasury markets. As Treasury supply grows relative to intermediaries’ capacity, Du and co-authors Benjamin Hébert of Stanford and Wenhao Li of USC argue, the convenience yield on Treasury securities declines.
- Treasuries traditionally have been a hedge for stock market investors; when stock markets fall, Treasuries rise in value. But after 2021, Viral Acharya and Toomas Laarits of NYU note, stock and bond markets have moved in the same direction, weakening demand for Treasury securities as a hedge, and pushing down the convenience yield.
Is the declining convenience yield a sign of the U.S. dollar falling out of favor with global investors?
No.
Demand from global investors for other dollar-denominated assets, such as equities and corporate bonds, has remained strong—largely because of the dollar’s dominant role in global payments and financing.
Despite the declining Treasury convenience yield following the Great Recession, dollar yield convenience has remained positive. Even following “Liberation Day” tariff announcements in April 2025 that were associated with a depreciation of the dollar and decline in Treasury convenience yields, the convenience yield on the dollar rose.
The Brookings Institution is committed to quality, independence, and impact.
We are supported by a diverse array of funders. In line with our values and policies, each Brookings publication represents the sole views of its author(s).
Commentary
What is happening to the convenience yield on US Treasuries?
November 20, 2026