Sections

Research

The defense budget: Costs and choices

Aerial view of the Pentagon complex with surrounding roads, parking and greenery.
Aerial view of the Pentagon. Photo: Shutterstock / Artem Onoprienko
Editor's note:

This research is part of a series prepared for “The Forces Shaping America’s Fiscal Future” conference at the University of Utah in June 2026.

Abstract

The U.S. defense budget balances national security requirements with growing fiscal pressures. Although defense spending is a smaller share of the budget than during the Cold War, strategic competition with China and Russia, regional threats from Iran and North Korea, and ongoing global commitments continue to drive support for a strong military. At the same time, rising personnel, healthcare, and modernization costs make controlling defense spending increasingly difficult. The paper argues that defense savings are possible but require difficult choices. The greatest savings would come from changes in national strategy, such as reducing overseas commitments, narrowing U.S. security obligations, or scaling back portions of the nuclear arsenal. The paper also explores personnel and force-structure reforms, acquisition and modernization programs, and infrastructure and administrative options. The paper recommends establishing independent commissions modeled on successful historical precedents, including an Iran war lessons-learned commission, a new base closure and realignment commission focused on headquarters and artificial intelligence efficiencies, and a total force personnel commission to optimize the mix of active-duty, reserve, civilian, and contractor personnel.   

Download full paper

Author

  • Acknowledgements and disclosures

    The author is a retired Marine colonel and senior adviser at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. This paper was written for the Brookings-Institution-University of Utah conference on “The Forces Shaping America’s Fiscal Future” in June 2026.

The Brookings Institution is committed to quality, independence, and impact.
We are supported by a diverse array of funders. In line with our values and policies, each Brookings publication represents the sole views of its author(s).