Sections

Commentary

Podcast

How we got here | The Deep Cuts Podcast, Episode 1

The origins of government and the consequences of DOGE for federal agencies, the civil service, and the American people

Co-hosts: Molly E. Reynolds and
Molly Reynolds
Molly E. Reynolds Vice President and Director - Governance Studies

Scott R. Anderson
Scott Anderson
Scott R. Anderson Senior Fellow - Governance Studies, General Counsel and Senior Editor - Lawfare
Participants: Nicholas R. Bednar, Elaine Kamarck, Gillian Metzger, and
Gillian Metzger Harlan Fiske Stone Professor of Law - Columbia Law School
Scott Levy
Scott Levy Counsel - Co-Equal

November 17, 2026


  • The dramatic changes to federal agencies pursued by the Trump administration seek to deconstruct a system that has developed over more than a century and has sought to make tradeoffs between accountability and the need for expertise to ensure effective governance. 
  • The Trump administration’s efforts to reshape government differ in important ways from prior efforts, such as President Clinton’s “Reinventing Government” effort. 
  • The Trump administration has used three main strategies to restructure the government: cutting personnel, controlling spending, and reducing agency activities to the minimum level required by law. 
  • While many of the administration’s actions have been challenged in court, many are still being litigated, as funds remain paused and staff remain on leave. 
Episode 1 How we got here
Photo illustration by Brookings; original photo: Orhan Cam/Shutterstock

In its first two years, the second Trump administration has pursued sweeping changes to what the federal government does, how it is staffed, and how its activities are paid for. In this episode, we discuss how we arrived at the administrative system we had before the overhaul, then detail how the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) and other executive branch actors disregarded key civil service protections and diverged from past government reform efforts. We then hear from experts on the distinct levers that have been used by the Trump administration to downsize, and in some cases eliminate, agencies, and programs. 

TRANSCRIPT

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: [00:00:00] What do you think of when you think of government? Sometimes, I bet, it’s America at its best. Soldiers defending the country, first responders keeping us safe, relief workers coming after a hurricane, public servants, patriots.  

PRESIDENT JOHN F. KENNEDY: And so my fellow Americans, ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country. 

TRACI DIMARTINI: Okay, how do we make the world better? That’s how I ended up in the federal government.  

PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: In the life of our nation, across every generation, there are those who stand apart. They step up, they take that oath, they put on the uniform, and they put their lives on the line.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: But at times, government can also seem like something much more oppressive, a burden imposed by others, constraints backed by the threat of violence. 

Tax bills, lines at the post office, red tape, waste, corruption, the deep state.  

PRESIDENT RONALD REAGAN: I’ve always felt the nine most terrifying words in the English language are, “I’m from the government, and I’m here to help.”  

REP. JEFF VAN DREW (R-NJ): The word I think of is corruption, how wrong all this is. People are so damn tired of this. American taxpayers-  

GIANNO CALDWELL: The American people see it for what it’s been, which is a sham  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: These narratives can be two sides of the same coin, the same phenomenon viewed from very different corners of our large and diverse country. 

And whether they are right or wrong, these sharply conflicting views of the same institutions are, if nothing else, a testament to the immense and incredibly complex, and incredibly contested, enterprise that is American government. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Nobody thinks government is perfect. Lots of people from across the political spectrum have very real, often very reasonable complaints about how the federal government does and doesn’t go about its work. [00:02:00] And when it’s working at its best, government often fades into the background. Water stays clean. 

Banks don’t fail. Bridges remain standing. Government makes sure that what you need is there when you need it, and otherwise stays out of the way. In other words, success can look a lot like nothing’s happening. You’ll barely notice until something breaks.  

ELON MUSK: Our goal is to reduce the waste and fraud by $4 billion a day, every day, seven days a week. 

LAURA INGRAHAM: This is why it’s so critical that DOGE scour every inch of our government. Remember, it’s your money. You earned it. Don’t let anyone else waste it.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: For the past two years, the federal government has been the subject of an unprecedented experiment. Since returning to the White House, President Donald Trump and his senior advisors have taken it upon themselves to refashion the federal government in a new image. 

KARA FELLOWS: President Trump signed roughly 140 executive orders during his nearly first 100 days in office.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: It’s the culmination of a project that had been percolating for years, one that ultimately manifested in Project 2025. It was a joint effort by conservative think tanks and former Trump staffers that set out a plan of action for a second Trump presidency. 

That plan viewed the federal government as, quote, “A behemoth, weaponized against American citizens and conservative values.” And its solution, in its own words, was a president with the, quote, “Boldness to bend or break the bureaucracy to the presidential will.”  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: This is more or less what the second Trump administration has worked to do. 

Beginning with the Department of Government Efficiency, or DOGE, set up under the stewardship of tech billionaire and Trump ally Elon Musk, it has uprooted massive numbers of federal employees, dismantled numerous offices and agencies, and withheld federal funding in countless areas, particularly where doing so serves [00:04:00] its preferred policy agenda. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Despite having allies in Congress, the Trump administration hasn’t sought much new legislation. Instead, it’s acted almost entirely through extraordinary, often unprecedented claims of presidential authority. And while DOGE as an agency has largely ceased operations, parts of this project are still being implemented through other corners of the federal government, like the Office of Management and Budget, headed by Russell Vought, one of the principal authors of Project 2025. 

RUSSELL VOUGHT: We want the bureaucrats to be traumatically affected. We want, when they wake up in the morning, we want them to not want to go to work. Because they are so, they are, they are increasingly viewed as the villains. We want to put them in trauma.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: My name is Scott R. Anderson.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: And I’m Molly Reynolds. We work at the Brookings Institution, where we study how government works and doesn’t work, and why. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: We and our colleagues have spent the past two years talking to many of the people affected by how the Trump administration has tried to transform the federal government, from current and former civil servants, to the people who implement and benefit from federal programs, to people who have been affected by government’s efforts to enforce the law. 

Our goal was to gain a better understanding of what this radical experiment in American government means, not just for them, but for all of us, as Americans.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Over the course of this series, you’ll meet many of these people. Each episode will dig into what exactly has happened within some of the agencies, offices, and programs affected by this effort. 

You’ll meet many of the people who, as civil servants, carried out the work of government.  

ERIKA MCENTARFER: You get up every day and know that you are doing intellectually challenging and rewarding things that are making the world a better place.  

DANNY WERFEL: There was something that maybe led me to believe that all paths [00:06:00] led to profit maximizing companies, and suddenly this new world opened up where the bottom line could be societal impact. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: You’ll also meet many others who have never worked in the federal government, but whose lives have been profoundly affected by it, for good and sometimes for ill.  

CHRIS GIVEN: Our goal was to make taxes as user-friendly as possible.  

ERIKA MCENTARFER: For every policy, one of the first questions is how many people is this gonna impact? 

You need data to figure that out.  

PAIGE DUGGINS-CLAY: Our mission is to help ensure that every young person, regardless of their zip code, what they look like, has access to a high quality public school.  

RACHEL WINOGRAD: Our overall goal is to reduce overdose and drug related harm.  

PARC SMITH: In federally declared natural disasters, teams are brought in to respond and help when people have really seen their lives devastated. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: But what’s happening to our government isn’t just about the people who worked there or the people they serve. It’s also about the role that government plays in our democracy. Government needs the power to do things, to execute. That’s the job. And for a country as large and complicated as today’s America, you need high-functioning, high-capacity agencies that can actually meet the modern needs of the country. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: Healthy governance also requires accountability, a way to hold officials responsible for the decisions it makes and what happens when it does or does not act. Where the government exercises power without ways to hold it accountable, it can undermine a healthy democracy. Our concern, and concern of many of the people we’ve talked to, is that the Trump administration’s actions have undermined both the government’s capacity to act and our ability to hold it accountable in ways that may be very hard to build back from. 

JEREMY KONYNDYK: If an administration can unilaterally decide, we can pass a budget, and then at our discretion, ignore what’s in it, we can have a congressionally mandated federal agency and just [00:08:00] decide it doesn’t exist anymore. That’s a constitutional issue. The balance of power and the separation of power is fundamental to the, the constitutional design of the U.S. government. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Recognizing the importance of government doesn’t mean that you think it’s perfect. It doesn’t mean that you can’t reform it or find ways to do things more efficiently and effectively. But it does mean you should do so carefully with consideration for the important things that government already does. 

TRACI DIMARTINI: If we’re gonna get serious about fixing federal government, we need to hold a mirror up to our face. You are not going to improve services to the government if you continue to malign the people that you employ to get those services accomplished.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: Because if you start undermining the institutions of government, you risk compromising something that’s been essential to making America what it is today. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: From the Brookings Institution, this is Deep Cuts: The Breaking and Rebuilding of American Government. 

Before we turn to recent events, it’s worth spending some time understanding how we got the government we have, and why so much of what the Trump administration has done represents a profound break with that history.  

NICK BEDNAR: At the founding, we write a new constitution, and we create a structure of government that is built around three branches: the legislative branch, the executive branch, and the judiciary. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: This is Nick Bednar, a law professor and political scientist who studies the federal workforce. If there’s one thing Bednar knows better than just about anyone, it’s our government and the rules that have governed the people who work in it over the past two and a half centuries.  

NICK BEDNAR: But if you look at what Article 2 says about administration itself, it’s pretty thin. 

And so early on, it is left to the president to really fill in the gaps of what administration is [00:10:00] going to look like. But it is really not until the Jackson administration  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: That’s in the 1830s.  

NICK BEDNAR: That we get what is known as the spoils system. And the spoils system has kind of two defining features to it. 

The first is patronage. Jackson didn’t think administration was particularly difficult, and he thought democracy demanded that administration be responsive to the public and the democratic will. So the spoils system is marked first and foremost by selection of individuals based on their partisan loyalties rather than their qualifications for office. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: In other words, the public elected a political party. So Jackson reasoned those administering the federal government should reflect those party values.  

NICK BEDNAR: The second thing is rotation in office. So upon the inauguration of a new president, that president is going to remove the current occupants of the office and replace them with their own preferred nominees and employees. 

There’s a way to reward voters who have supported you during your campaign. The problem with this system is that it’s a really detrimental system to administrative capacity.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: So even if an administrator got their job through having the right politics rather than skill, all the expertise they gained in that job will be lost as soon as they were replaced in the next administration. 

Every four years, any learning, any specialization would reset to zero.  

NICK BEDNAR: A lot of governance depends on kind of institutional memory and the ability of the agency to remember how it has done things in the past, right? Learning how to govern is a very hard task.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: Not only did this stymie expertise, but it came with [00:12:00] other costs. 

NICK BEDNAR: A consequence of this spoils system is we see a lot of corruption in agencies like the Customs Service, the Naval Yards, the Post Office, where basically individuals occupy these positions for about four years and they use it to seek rents and kind of loot the federal government of the money that is otherwise set aside for running government. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: It took an assassination to change the spoils system. In 1881, President James Garfield was shot by a former supporter who believed he was owed a position in government and hadn’t been given one.  

NICK BEDNAR: As a result of this, Congress passes the Pendleton Act, and the Pendleton Act has a few guarantees. So the first guarantee is that agencies, you’re going to select people through competitive examination. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Anyone who wanted to work for the federal government was required to take a series of exams administered by a body known as the Civil Service Commission.  

NICK BEDNAR: The second big characteristic of the Pendleton Act is that agencies were prohibited from basing employment decisions, either selection or removal, based on partisan politics.

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: A system formerly built around personal politics now made it illegal to remove employees for political reasons. By 1900, about 40% of the federal workforce was protected by the merit system under the Pendleton Act, and Congress continued to roll out other protections too.  

NICK BEDNAR: In 1912, Congress passes the Lloyd-La Follette Act, and the purpose of the Lloyd-La Follette Act is to provide employees with tenure protection. 

So it says that agencies should not remove individuals except for cause as necessary for the efficiency of the service.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: The problem with all of these protections is that there wasn’t an easy route to enforcing them.  

NICK BEDNAR: Slowly, the Civil Service Commission gets some [00:14:00] degree of control over the ability to hear claims brought by civil servants who were removed without cause. 

But the real revolution starts happening in the 1970s, and it happens with the federal courts. Federal courts in a series of decisions start saying that actually we believe public employment when it has tenure protections like those provided by the Lloyd-La Follette Act, that is a constitutionally protected property interest, and therefore you are entitled to due process before you’re removed from your position. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: To manage this process, Congress eventually enacts a law called the Civil Service Reform Act in 1978, which breaks apart the old Civil Service Commission and replaces it with a handful of new entities, including the Merit Systems Protection Board, or MSPB.  

NICK BEDNAR: The Merit Systems Protection Board is the agency that’s effectively a quasi court that adjudicates disputes between federal employees and the federal government. 

It is the protector of the civil service laws, and the prosecutor of the civil service laws is the Office of Special Counsel. And those individuals are supposed to be independent from the president because they are designed to protect the civil service from the president’s political machinations and desire to control the workforce. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: By the late 20th century, you’ve gone from the spoils system to what is recognizable as our modern civil service system.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: The key elements of this system, merit-based hiring, ensuring one can’t be fired for political reasons, and tenure protections, were designed to ensure consistent expert support for the administration of government. 

But they also represent a key piece in the accountability puzzle. Employees who aren’t worried [00:16:00] about being removed for having the wrong politics are, we’d hope, more likely to report wrongdoing or to adhere to the law rather than to their political superiors when the two conflict. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: At the same time all of this was happening with the civil service, the size and reach of the federal government was changing too.  

NICK BEDNAR: And during the Industrial Revolution, Congress becomes very concerned with regulating aspects of the economy where citizens are being hurt pretty regularly. You have the invention of the railroad system and the moguls who are now engaged in a lot of monopolistic practices that are not good for pricing. 

You start to see concerns about health and safety regulations with respect to slaughterhouses, food manufacturing, and factories. And by about the time of the New Deal, we also start to see an expansion of social welfare programs. And it’s during this time that we get Social Security. And by the 60s, we get things like Medicare and Medicaid. 

And so there’s this vast expansion of what the federal government is regulating and also the services it’s providing to individuals.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: As the federal government becomes more powerful and more involved in citizens’ day-to-day lives, it puts the civil service and the agencies they staff in a complicated position. 

On the one hand, it becomes more important than ever for the government to be staffed by experts who know what they are doing, who can use this new power both responsibly and effectively, and ensure that it’s kept within the limits of the law. But it also raises concerns that the growth in government is empowering civil servants too much, that by insulating them from political control, Congress has also insulated them from political accountability, that as a result, the federal government has become too free to be [00:18:00] inefficient or wasteful, or even committed to a policy agenda that’s too independent from the elected political leaders who are supposed to be making those policy decisions. 

NICK BEDNAR: You start to see a shift where conservatives in particular become very concerned about administrative governance, and we see an attack on both the civil service and federal agencies more broadly from individuals who believe in smaller government and deregulation.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: But conservatives aren’t the only ones who’ve asked questions about the size and scope of government. 

One of the first presidents to do so seriously was a Democrat from the state of Arkansas named Bill Clinton.  

ELAINE KAMARCK: Our theory of the case, because remember, this was nineteen ninety-three, ninety-four.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: This is Elaine Kamarck, now a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution. In the early 1990s, she worked with Vice President Al Gore and others in the Clinton administration to lead a major effort to reform how agencies did business, known as Reinventing Government. 

ELAINE KAMARCK: Our theory of the case was that the information age allowed you to shrink your span of control in management because you didn’t need layers of people checking the work of layers of other people.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: In many ways, Reinventing Government was an early precursor to DOGE, but it went about its work in a very different way. 

Understanding how and why can help shed some light on the approach the Trump administration has taken.  

ELAINE KAMARCK: We focused on middle management and not on frontline employees. And by that I mean, you know, the guy who is stamping your passport as you come into the United States.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: In order to reinvent government, Kaymark and her colleagues needed to know what was actually happening in the myriad parts of federal agencies. 

To do that, they turned to the people who knew those agencies best: civil servants.  

ELAINE KAMARCK: [00:20:00] We set about creating teams that looked at every cabinet agency and looked at a series of cross-cutting issues like budgeting, procurement, civil service, et cetera. And the teams went off and did studies, basically, of the agencies. 

We determined early on that we were going to use civil servants from various branches of government, and so what we did is we recruited people from the government who were known to be innovators. One thing we did is make sure that nobody worked on their own agency. Teams met together for months and months and months, dealing with, you know, whatever the problems were. 

And then we went through a series of, you know, reviews of this. I mean, we spent one entire weekend with the president in our jeans and sneakers going through one agency report after another after another with recommendations.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: The Clinton administration looked first to the executive branch itself to see what could be implemented. 

ELAINE KAMARCK: There’s an awful lot of just plain old management stuff that the federal government, the way they organize to do their work. We went to Congress when we saw that something was a statutory problem. Other than that, it was really within the purview of really the senior civil servant running the agency to figure out how you staffed that and how you did that, et cetera. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: But there were statutory problems, requirements and restrictions embedded into the law that might have made sense when Congress adopted them were now inhibiting the modernization of the executive branch. And to fix these, Kamarck and her colleagues did what they understood you had to do to change the law. 

They turned to Congress.  

ELAINE KAMARCK: That grew out of that team effort coming together and saying, “We need to change the law.” So in this [00:22:00] process, we would say, “Oh, yeah. Well, they do it that way because there’s this statute that’s from 1954,” right? And we would say, “Oh, well, we don’t need that anymore,” okay? And, and we’d go to Congress, and most of the time, these were non-ideological asks, so we had a fairly easy time in Congress. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: In fact, the main legislation that came out of this effort passed both the House and Senate with strong support from both major parties. When all was said and done, reinventing government saved about $146 billion. Federal employment fell as well. And while employment levels have crept up slightly since then, overall employment levels among core federal employees stayed pretty flat.

That is, until 2025.  

REBEKAH CASTOR: Trump has tasked Musk with weeding out waste and fraud within the federal government, a project that’s been dubbed DOGE.  

MAJOR GARRETT: DOGE, the Department of Government Efficiency, will be intensifying its efforts to overhaul the federal government. That’s putting it mildly. It says this in part, quote, “What is happening to the US government right now is bad. 

What comes next is worse.”  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: On January 20th, 2025, the day he was inaugurated for his second term, President Trump issued a series of executive orders. One of the most notable created the Department of Government Efficiency, or DOGE, a new office within the White House headed by Elon Musk, and mostly staffed by individuals from the tech industry with no prior experience in government. 

Today, DOGE has become an umbrella term for much of what’s happened to the government since January 2025. It’s a shorthand for a set of tools deployed across dozens of federal agencies, some through DOGE itself, others through the Office of Management and Budget, and some through agencies’ own political leadership. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: The full scope of what the Trump administration has done to the federal government is complex and hard to [00:24:00] comprehend. It involves countless decisions and policies implemented by hundreds of officials across dozens of federal agencies. But to understand the events we’re going to be talking about over the course of the series, it’s useful to think of the Trump administration as pursuing three big moves in its efforts to restructure the federal government. 

First, cutting personnel. Second, controlling spending. And third, reducing agency activities to the minimum required under the law. The first of these moves related to the civil service came fast and furious as soon as President Trump entered office.  

MATT GALKA: A dramatic reshaping of the federal government continues under President Donald Trump. 

BRIAN BARRETT: You know, already DOGE has fired thousands of federal workers. They’ve canceled thousands of government contracts. They plan to fire many, many, many more. Each of those government workers does something. Each of those federal contracts serves some purpose.  

MATT GALKA: Critics say gutting the government workforce could mean getting rid of non-political employees who know how to actually run the government. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: In terms of government personnel-  

NICK BEDNAR: The most novel thing that the Trump administration attempted, and ultimately succeeded, I should say, is the Deferred Resignation Program, or DRP  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: This is Nick Bednar again. He says eight days into the second Trump administration, more than two million federal employees received a letter from the US Office of Personnel Management, or OPM. 

The memo was titled Fork in the Road, and was an official offer.  

NICK BEDNAR: DRP is this program essentially offering employees that if they voluntarily agree to resign, then they will be guaranteed pay up till the end of the fiscal year in September, and that they’ll be placed on administrative leave. And the idea of the program, according to the Trump administration, is that we are envisioning a massive shakeup of the [00:26:00] administrative state, and this is your opportunity to get out, be placed on administrative leave, and still get paid while you are going to find jobs elsewhere. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: It also seemed like things were not going to be very pleasant within the government.  

NICK BEDNAR: You also have a lot of workplace changes that are making the workplace just more hostile. The administration has made it very clear that its goal is to traumatize the workforce, and it’s doing so pretty effectively. It cuts telework for a lot of employees on day one and says they have to return to the office.

It begins threatening to move people out of Washington or wherever they are currently stationed. And then you also have a bunch of weird confusion about new personnel policies, like this email that gets sent out by DOGE saying, “You need to tell us the five things you did this week.” So set aside whether you’ve actually been removed, there’s a whole separate question of, do you even want to remain at this place? 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: But there were still big questions about the DRP and about whether it was actually legal and whether the Trump administration would make good on its promises. Courts held up some aspects of the program for a while, but because people volunteered to take the deal, the DRP was allowed to proceed. And ultimately, the Trump administration made the offer several more times. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: Meanwhile, for employees who didn’t take the deal or otherwise leave on their own terms, the Trump administration had other strategies. The first targeted what are known as probationary employees, civil servants who had only been in their roles a year or two and thus didn’t receive the full range of tenure protections extended to federal employees. 

In February, the White House ordered federal agencies to fire probationary employees en masse. To do so, they had to claim that all of these employees’ performances had been insufficient, even though most had never received a negative [00:28:00] performance review. Unsurprisingly, people sued, but the Supreme Court ultimately allowed the firings to proceed while the government’s actions were being challenged. 

NICK BEDNAR: The district judge in California basically says, “I believe the Trump administration violated the law, but too much time has passed. Most of these individuals have moved on, and so we can’t put them back in their positions.”  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: For non-probationary employees, the Trump administration turned to yet another strategy, one that already existed in law but had never before been used at scale. 

It’s called a reduction in force, or RIF.  

NICK BEDNAR: So reductions in force are this strategy agencies use when they need to reduce the size of their workforce, usually because of budget cuts or reorganization or a lack of work. There is some administrative need that requires the agency to shuffle its employees around, and there’s a very complicated procedure that agencies are supposed to follow in implementing reductions in force. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Reductions in force usually require agencies to consider the tenure, performance, and veteran status of employees, but that’s not what the Trump administration did in 2025.  

NICK BEDNAR: So in mid-February, the Trump administration issues an executive order instructing agencies to begin mass reductions in force, and it instructs these agencies to reduce their workforces to the amount statutorily allowable under law. 

In other words, keep only the employees you need to implement mandatory programs.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Tenure and other measures were supposed to protect federal employees from this sort of arbitrary termination. But the institution Congress had set up to give federal employees a place to bring those claims, it wasn’t working like it was supposed to. 

NICK BEDNAR: The big problem with the Merit Systems [00:30:00] Protection Board at this time is it lacks a quorum. And so these individuals, these employees who are being removed pursuant to reductions in force, don’t have a way to get past the Merit Systems Protection Board. They are not permitted under law to jump straight to federal court. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: Unions and other groups took the RIFs to court, and judges paused several of them. Some of those cases are still being litigated today, with employees stuck on administrative leave while they wait. Other RIFs were called off by the administration itself, which realized it still needed those workers. By January 2026, the full scope of what this all meant for the federal government began to come into focus. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Almost four hundred thousand federal employees separated from the government in the second Trump administration’s first year, and the vast majority did so voluntarily, either through the DRP or more conventional resignation or retirement. The Government Accountability Office estimated that the DRP alone cost American taxpayers six point seven billion dollars to pay civil servants’ salaries while they were not working. 

By some measures, it was the largest cut in federal staffing since the 1990s and brought overall federal employment levels to those not seen since the 1960s. Now for the second move by the Trump administration, control of spending. The Constitution is clear about who controls federal money  

GILLIAN METZGER: The power of the purse, the power to spend lies with Congress, lies with the legislative branch. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: This is Gillian Metzger, a professor at Columbia Law School. She also served in the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel under President Biden.  

GILLIAN METZGER: In Article I, which is what describes the powers of Congress, it leads with, among other things, saying that Congress shall have the power to pay the debts and to pay for the general welfare. 

So that’s a spending power that Congress has. The Constitution then [00:32:00] reinforces that. It also says in another section of Article I that you can’t have any appropriation payment that isn’t based on an appropriation made by law, which means by statute. So you have this mutually reinforcing system where the power is granted to Congress in the spending clause, and then the appropriations clause says you can’t have any spending that isn’t by an appropriation, a measure passed by Congress. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Early on, a big problem for Congress was that the executive branch would sometimes spend more money than the legislature wanted to appropriate.  

GILLIAN METZGER: Congress would appropriate money, and then the executive branch would overcommit, and then Congress was sort of forced to provide additional funds to make up the difference. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: In 1870, Congress addressed this problem by enacting a law called the Anti-Deficiency Act, which prohibits anyone in the government from spending more money than Congress has allocated for a given purpose. But in the 1970s, President Richard Nixon presented Congress with a different sort of appropriations conundrum: not spending the money the legislature had told the executive to spend. 

GILLIAN METZGER: So what, what Nixon tried to do, there were a number of areas, clean water grants, sewer funding, highway funding, where he thought that Congress had appropriated too much money. He wanted to cut back on what was being spent, and so he refused to spend some of the money that had been appropriated and committed. 

And this led, not surprisingly, to a number of lawsuits challenging that. The courts agreed, including the Supreme Court. These were mandatory. The government was required to provide the funds.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: Congress pushed back against Nixon in 1974 with the Impoundment Control Act. If the president wanted to cancel funds Congress had appropriated, the law said, he had to follow specific steps, and those steps included Congress. 

GILLIAN METZGER: The president cannot refuse to spend on policy grounds because the president, as a policy matter, disagrees with Congress’s spending choices.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: If the president wants to [00:34:00] cancel funds completely, he can use a method spelled out in the Impoundment Control Act known as a rescission. To start the rescission process, the president sends a message to Congress. 

GILLIAN METZGER: Congress has 45 days to decide whether or not they’re gonna approve it. The key thing about the rescission is if Congress doesn’t approve it, it doesn’t go forward, and after 45 days, the executive branch has to make the funds available for obligation if Congress hasn’t approved it.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: Because of this legal framework, there has traditionally been a huge amount of consultation and engagement between the executive branch and Congress in figuring out how much to spend and how to structure that spending. 

But-  

GILLIAN METZGER: The current Trump administration, Trump 2, is deviating from past practices. One of the main things that we’ve seen is mass cancellation of grants, whether it’s National Science Foundation or major funding and grants to states through disaster aid, transportation projects, education, just tremendous cancellation of grants across the board. 

These are cancellations not just of money waiting to be obligated for grants, but in many instances, actual already obligated funds.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Funds are obligated when they’re entered into grants with organizations to perform certain services. Canceling money that’s already been obligated is not just a rejection of Congress’s decisions. 

It’s also incredibly disruptive to the functioning of programs.  

GILLIAN METZGER: For example, disaster aid, particularly when for requests from Democratically led states, it’s been refusing to pay out on that. Foreign assistance aid is one major example where it just refused.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Many of these funding moves have been challenged in federal courts, and a good number have been reversed as unlawful.

But in other cases, federal courts have allowed the federal government to continue withholding funds while the lawsuit played out. So the money stays frozen even if the freeze is later ruled unlawful.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: One of the Trump [00:36:00] administration’s boldest moves didn’t come until September 2025, as the federal government approached the end of its fiscal year. 

If appropriated funds haven’t been spent by then, many of them expire. That’s when President Trump decided he wanted to use the rescission process. He asked Congress to pull back some of the funds he didn’t wanna spend after all. But there was a catch.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Because it was the end of the fiscal year, the money would expire before the 45 days were up. 

The president wouldn’t have to get Congress’s approval, the approval required under the law. He could just run out the clock. This is called a pocket rescission. It’s a rare tactic, and according to the Government Accountability Office, it’s illegal.  

SCOTT LEVY: You know, if I’m, uh, congressional Democrats, I, I might be very concerned that any area where I get an increase in funding might just be undermined through a pocket rescission. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Scott Levy was the general counsel for the White House in the Office of Pandemic Preparedness and Response Policy. He’s speaking here in a personal capacity. Levy imagines the view of a pocket rescission from Congress.  

SCOTT LEVY: It’s hard to have a lot of faith that a policy win or a, you know, appropriations win will translate to a reality absence from some credible assurance from the Trump administration. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Regardless of how it’s been done, there’s no doubt that the Trump administration’s tight grip on federal spending has had consequences. By one count, more than $170 billion in funding has been cut, frozen, or delayed since President Trump returned to office.

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: Then there’s the third move we talked about: reducing agency activities to the minimum required by law. 

Congress provides every agency with statutes spelling out, in varying degrees of detail, what the agency is supposed to do. Often, Congress adds to or changes those statutes over time, and presidents have always had some discretion in [00:38:00] how to enforce those laws. Here’s Scott Levy again.  

SCOTT LEVY: The executive branch has a lot of discretion to operate within the limits of those statutes, but the structure, the overall goal, the mission, all of that is, is set by Congress, and the executive branch can’t simply decide, “We don’t like this mission. 

We want to do something else,” or, “We don’t like this mission. We don’t want the agency to exist any longer.” That’s not an inherent power in the presidency and, you know, the president actually has a, a responsibility to faithfully execute the law under the Constitution. And so they are really responsible for executing the vision born out in the statute, not some policy vision independent of that. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: But the Trump administration hasn’t taken that approach. Instead, in case after case after case, it’s proven willing to read a statute incredibly, often implausibly narrowly to avoid having the government do things it would rather not do. You’ve already heard a few examples of this. Think back to the executive order President Trump issued in February 2025 directing agencies to draw up initial plans for massive RIFs. 

SCOTT LEVY: So shortly after taking office, President Trump issued an executive order directing agencies to come up with plans for reductions in force, or RIFs, to lay off personnel, and it really did that with an eye towards sort of, like, what is the statutory minimum that we have to actually satisfy?  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: Obviously, when Congress creates an agency and gives it a statutory mandate, things it is supposed to regulate or enforce, it’s directing a level of activity above what that agency has to do during a shutdown. 

But that’s what the Trump administration proposed using as a baseline for what agencies should be staffed to do all the time, even when fully funded.  

SCOTT LEVY: And, and arguably, it went even further than that by saying, like, you know, look at an agency shutdown plans to help figure out that RIF, and what an agency does during a shutdown is [00:40:00] actually less than its statutory minimums. 

It’s a subset of things that it needs to do really to, like, protect, like, human life and safety.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: This strategy doesn’t make a lot of sense if you’re trying to faithfully execute the mandate that Congress has given you. But it does make sense if what you care about more than that mandate is shrinking the federal government, and if you’re willing to interpret the law aggressively to get there. 

SCOTT LEVY: They’ve sort of done this right off the bat as sort of like a policy goal. You know, trying to do the statutory minimums and highlighting, you know, the select functions that actually say in the statute shall, um, meaning an agency has a duty to do it, versus may, which means an agency can choose to do it. 

I think the, the sort of underlying current of we only need to do the bare minimum is certainly consistent in how the Trump administration talks about their responsibilities generally.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: A lot of the time, doing the bare minimum has involved an agency just doing less. But in other cases, it’s involved taking tasks from one agency and giving them to another agency to do instead. 

And a tool the Trump administration has used to do that is a law called the Economy Act.  

SCOTT LEVY: And so what the Economy Act does is it says one agency can contract with another agency to perform a function when it’s more cost effective or convenient than the agency either doing it itself or relying on some private party.

It’s an exception to the general rule that an agency can’t delegate its functions to another agency to do something.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: It’s smart cost efficiency. Why reinvent the wheel when another agency already has one?  

SCOTT LEVY: So you might imagine, like, there’s a new agency formed, and they need to set up a payroll system. 

Well, they could either set up that payroll system themselves, or they could hire an agency with an existing payroll system to do it for them.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: The Economy Act authorizes them to do just that: to collaborate functions across [00:42:00] agencies. But the Trump administration realized that, if interpreted aggressively, the Economy Act could be used to do something different, to shift funds and functions across federal agencies in ways Congress never envisioned. 

And ironically, one of the best examples of this may be DOGE itself  

SCOTT LEVY: When the Trump administration came in, they created DOGE out of what was the US Digital Service, and the president and executive order directed each agency to create its own DOGE unit. And as part of that, the White House DOGE assigned personnel to agencies under the Economy Act. 

And what that means is White House personnel were working in agencies on things like RIFs, on managing contracts and IT systems, in some cases getting access to very sensitive data on taxpayers, Social Security beneficiaries, and the like. And at the same time, their services were being paid for by the agency itself. 

So the agency head is having some of its power shifted to this new DOGE unit, and it’s sort of like paying for the privilege of seeing its power diminished. But it’s also, in essence, then a way for the White House to expand its budget. By relying on the Economy Act, they’re sort of shifting funds away from the departments and agencies and towards the White House. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: But the Trump administration’s use of the Economy Act doesn’t end with DOGE. Elsewhere, the Trump administration has used the same law to effectively take whole functions within one agency and transfer them to another, often with the goal of shutting that first agency down. Agencies like the Department of Education, which we’ll return to in one of our later episodes. 

SCOTT LEVY: It’s been described as sort of like an effort to test if other departments can do Department of Education’s functions more effectively and efficiently. But that’s also not truly the, the intent of the Economy Act. And, you know, the president has talked about, you know, wanting to end the Department of [00:44:00] Education. 

It’s been described as, you know, the last mission, I think, by the secretary.  

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Like other actions, the Trump administration’s aggressive pursuit of statutory minimums has been challenged in court. And those challenges have had some success, particularly in pushing back on proposals to effectively wind down places like The Voice of America or the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, another federal agency we’ll return to in a later episode. 

But many more interpretations haven’t been challenged, in part because it’s not always clear who has standing to sue. These dynamics highlight one final thing about all three of these moves that’s worth emphasizing. Almost none of what the Trump administration has done has actually been fully vindicated in a final court decision. 

When the Trump administration has won, the decisions have mostly been about what happens to the parties and their interests while the dispute is being litigated.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: When it comes to the former federal employees and federal grantees who have pursued most of these legal challenges, the courts have often ruled that Congress has set up different special processes for addressing their claims. 

But most of those special procedures don’t allow for employees to be reinstated or grants to be fulfilled while the dispute is ongoing. Instead, the Trump administration gets to set the status quo while the cases are being litigated. Federal courts may ultimately issue final rulings against the Trump administration. 

Civil servants and grantees might be awarded compensation or even reinstatement, but it could be years before any of these cases get resolved. This means that President Trump is likely to get much of what he wants while he’s still in the White House, and the consequences of his actions will be left for his successors to figure out once he’s gone. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: All the lost [00:46:00] jobs, all the disrupted funding and programming, these all had consequences for people out in the world beyond Washington, people who need the things that government does. The next several episodes will introduce these programs and the people who carry them out. The volunteer tax preparer who watched her clients stop trusting the IRS with their information. 

The foreign service officer who spent his career answering disasters, watching his legacy disappear over a matter of weeks. You’ll also hear about these three maneuvers: cutting personnel, controlling spending, and embracing statutory minimums again and again in different combinations at different agencies with different consequences for people in the United States and around the world. 

You’ll learn about the impact these actions have had on the institutions of the federal government and on the tools we use to hold our leaders accountable. And you’ll hear about how the decline of both has impacted countless Americans.  

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: Then in our last episode, we’ll take a look at what might come next in the aftermath of the Trump administration’s experiment. 

We are currently in uncharted territory when it comes to our federal government. Across the federal bureaucracy, the Trump administration’s unprecedented overhaul is pushing many of the things we take for granted about our government to the brink, and it may make it more difficult to rebuild the government we need. 

CO-HOST MOLLY REYNOLDS: Next time on Deep Cuts: The U.S. Agency for International Development.  

CHRIS MILLIGAN: The dismantling of USAID has not only had a devastating impact on lives and communities overseas, we’ve weakened our international leadership at considerable risks to ourselves.  

ANDREW NATSIOS: The consequence is that there’s no medicines, and people are dying. 

Just this year, 800,000 people have died because all the supply chain systems have been destroyed.  

NICK ENRICH: One of [00:48:00] the things that kind of keeps me up all night is that we haven’t even started to really see the worst of it yet. 

CO-HOST SCOTT ANDERSON: Deep Cuts is a production of the Brookings Institution and Goat Rodeo. You can follow the series on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. For Goat Rodeo, the lead producer of this episode is Jay Venables, with production support from Cara Shillin and Ian Enright. Production assistance from Hazel Hoffman. 

For the Brookings Institution, the lead producers are Molly Reynolds and me, Scott R. Anderson. Fact-checking by Abby Ward. Series graphics and visuals by Adelle Patten. Additional thanks to Vanessa Williamson, Massi Colonna, Ellis Chen, and Nancy Lauffer. The communications director for the Governance Studies program at Brookings is Jenna Portnoy. 

Music from Alibi and Blue Dot Sessions. A special thank you to all of the interviewees who made this show possible. 

Participants

  • Footnotes
    1. 1 https://static.heritage.org/project2025/2025_MandateForLeadership_FULL.pdf
    2. 2 https://www.wired.com/story/what-is-doge-doing-now/
    3. 3 https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/pendleton-act
    4. 4  https://www2.census.gov/library/publications/1975/compendia/hist_stats_colonial-1970/hist_stats_colonial-1970p2-chY.pdf
    5. 5 https://whistleblower.house.gov/resources/all-resources/committee-jurisdiction-tool/whistleblowing-executive-branch-employee/lloyd-la-follette-act-1912
    6. 6 https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R44803.html
    7. 7 https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-merit-systems-protection-board-s-independence-is-dead
    8. 8 https://www.congress.gov/bill/103rd-congress/senate-bill/2170/all-actions ; https://www.congress.gov/bill/103rd-congress/senate-bill/20/all-info
    9. 9 https://apnews.com/article/trump-musk-doge-clinton-reinventing-government-gore-a95795eb75cacc03734ef0065c1b0a6d 
    10. 10 https://www.brookings.edu/articles/has-government-been-reinvented/
    11. 11 https://www.stlouisfed.org/on-the-economy/2025/apr/historical-geographical-look-federal-employment-levels  
    12. 12 https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/establishing-and-implementing-the-presidents-department-of-government-efficiency/
    13. 13 https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/02/27/us/politics/doge-staff-list.html
    14. 14 https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/breaking-down-opm-s–fork-in-the-road–email-to-federal-workers
    15. 15 https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/return-to-in-person-work/
    16. 16 https://abcnews.com/US/tech-issues-hit-doges-5-things-email-requirement/story?id=120189752
    17. 17 https://news.bloomberglaw.com/daily-labor-report/exit-deal-for-federal-workers-can-resume-after-judge-ends-hold
    18. 18 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/white-house/trump-administration-federal-agencies-fire-probationary-employees-rcna192149
    19. 19 https://www.govexec.com/workforce/2025/02/trump-administration-directs-agencies-fire-recent-hires-en-masse/403017/
    20. 20 https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2025/07/08/supreme-court-trump-mass-layoffs-federal-workers/
    21. 21 https://www.opm.gov/policy-data-oversight/workforce-restructuring/reductions-in-force-rif/
    22. 22 https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/02/implementing-the-presidents-department-of-government-efficiency-workforce-optimization-initiative/
    23. 23 https://federalnewsnetwork.com/government-shutdown/2025/10/court-blocks-trump-administrations-latest-mass-layoffs-for-federal-employees/
    24. 24 https://www.afge.org/article/summary-of-afge-lawsuits-against-trump–how-litigation-works-2/
    25. 25 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/white-house/trump-administration-reverses-layoffs-cdc-staff-rcna237136
    26. 26 https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-26-108477
    27. 26 https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-26-108477
    28. 28 https://nypost.com/2026/09/30/us-news/us-federal-workforce-drops-to-lowest-level-in-60-years-after-trump-purged-hundreds-of-thousands/
    29. 29 https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R48432
    30. 30 https://www.highereddive.com/news/inside-the-federal-keyword-lists-that-canceled-billions-in-research-funding/826203/
    31. 31 https://www.politico.com/news/2026/07/29/fema-democratic-disaster-requests-trump-01013938
    32. 32 https://www.newsfromthestates.com/article/wisconsin-coalition-states-win-lawsuit-against-trump-administration-cutting-federal-grants ; https://www.aaup.org/about/programs/legal-program/aaup-litigation/court-rules-favor-aaup-harvard-grant-termination-case
    33. 33 https://www.americanprogress.org/article/what-is-a-pocket-rescission/
    34. 34 https://www.lostfunds.org/
    35. 35 https://www.acquisition.gov/far/17.502-2
    36. 36 https://www.propublica.org/article/doge-trump-musk-funding-foia-congress-transparency
    37. 37 https://www.congress.gov/119/meeting/house/118875/documents/HHRG-119-JU13-20260121-SD002-U2.pdf
    38. 38 https://www.politico.com/news/2025/11/18/trump-administration-sets-out-massive-education-department-restructuring-plan-00656464
    39. 39 https://www.ed.gov/about/news/speech/secretary-mcmahon-our-departments-final-mission
    40. 40 https://www.rcfp.org/voice-of-america-back-to-work-order/
    41. 41 https://www.legal500.com/intelligence/united-states/finance-and-banking/dc-circuit-reinstates-injunction-blocking-cfpb%27s-mass-layoffs

The Brookings Institution is committed to quality, independence, and impact.
We are supported by a diverse array of funders. In line with our values and policies, each Brookings publication represents the sole views of its author(s).