The Intersection of Politics and Policy Is a Lonely Place

“The intersection of politics and policy is a lonely place,” writes Senior Fellow Elaine Kamarck in her new book How Change Happens—Or Doesn’t: The Politics of U.S. Public Policy. In this podcast, Kamarck, founding director of the Center for Effective Public Management, touches on the ideas and examples in her book to explain why politics and policy have to come together for us to understand success and failure in U.S. politics.

Kamarck talks about “surveying the policy battlefield” in trying to understand the complexity of change. For example, why did unpopular President Harry Truman manage to get the Marshall Plan passed “with a hostile Republican Congress,” while Barack Obama, who “came into office on the heels of a robust political victory” with majorities in both houses of Congress, failed to enact climate change legislation?

The conversation ranged from how FDR’s social policies reflected American values, to whether the Affordable Care Act does, to the complexity and length of modern legislation, to whether or not elections matter and if mandates exist outside politician’s own minds.



Show notes:

Lessons from the Shutdown: Management Matters, Even for Presidents, by Elaine Kamarck
FixGov blog
The Semi-Sovereign People: A Realist’s View of Democracy in America, by E.E. Schattschneider
Myth of the Presidential Mandate, by Robert Dahl