Quality. Independence. Impact.

Home | Contact Us | Media Resources

Sunday November 22, 2009

Welcome   |   Register   |   Log in

Past Event

A Governance Studies Event

Health Care Reform: Should We Expand Our Public Plan?

Health Care, Health IT


Event Summary

With high health care costs and the large number of uninsured, many Americans are ready for fundamental changes. Congress has already appropriated money for health information technology designed to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the current system. The harder task will be achieving consensus on the legislation moving forward that establishes a new public insurance plan, requires individuals to own insurance and mandates that businesses provide insurance for their employees.

Event Information

When

Thursday, July 09, 2009
10:00 AM to 11:30 AM

Where

Falk Auditorium
The Brookings Institution
1775 Massachusetts Ave., NW
Washington, DC
Map

Event Materials

Contact: Brookings Office of Communications

E-mail: events@brookings.edu

Phone: 202.797.6105


Multimedia Downloads

Full Event Audio

July 09, 2009 Length: 1:25:44

On July 9, the Brookings Institution hosted an event to discuss the pros and cons of expanding the public plan, how to reduce costs while expanding coverage and the central role of information technology in health reform. Darrell West, Brookings vice president and director of Governance Studies and co-author of Digital Medicine: Health Care in the Internet Era (Brookings Institution Press, 2009), moderated the discussion with Geoffrey Garin, president of Peter Hart Research Associates; Richard Kirsch, national campaign manager of Health Care for America Now; John Linkous, CEO of American Telemedicine Association; and Scott Keefer, vice president of America's Health Insurance Plans.

After the program, panelists took audience questions.

Transcript

DARRELL WEST:  A few months ago our political leaders signaled their intention to pass comprehensive health care reform by this fall, and of course now we are seeing House and Senate Committees marking up various bills. There've been high-profile meetings at the White House. Various industry groups have pledged to cut costs, which have been soaring well above the rate of inflation. We don't know exactly what the ultimate proposal's going to look like, but legislation has been proposed that establishes a new public insurance plan, requires individuals to own insurance, and mandates that businesses provide insurance for their employees, among other features.

Proponents have argued that these steps are absolutely vital in order to save money, improve quality, and provide health care to those who need it. Opponents argue that we should not expand the role of the government in health care, that we should not have public plans competing with private insurance companies, and that the price tag for those proposed changes is way too expensive. Public opinion remains quite complicated on health care reform. A recent New York Times/CBS national survey found that 61 percent of Americans believe the rising cost of health care represents a very serious threat to our national economy, and 59 percent believe that the government actually would do a better job than private companies in holding down the cost of health care. But at the same time, 77 percent of Americans have indicated that they are satisfied with the quality of the health care that they personally receive.

On top of all this, it's unclear how some of the new advances in health information technology, telemedicine, and mobile health through cell phones relate to the broader effort at health care reform. I have a book, Digital Medicine: Health Care in the Internet Era, and I note that there are many exciting developments taking place in the area of new technology in health care. In fact, many argue that new technology actually is the key to long-term cost savings in this area. But we need to figure out how to use technology to reform organizations, change cultures, and alter reimbursement rates, because if we don't get the incentives right, health care reform is not going to be successful no matter what ends up in the final package.

Participants

Moderator

Darrell M. West

Vice President and Director, Governance Studies

Panelists

Geoffrey Garin

President, Peter Hart Research Associates

Scott Keefer

Vice President, America's Health Insurance Plans

Richard Kirsch

National Campaign Manager, Health Care for America Now

John Linkous

CEO, American Telemedicine Association


My Portfolio

My New Content

View suggested content based on items you have saved to your Portfolio.
Log in or register now